What's the truth behind 5 gardening myths?

CORVALLIS, Ore. – As the gardening season gears up, it’s time to bust some myths.

How many times have you heard that leaving grass clippings on the lawn will promote thatch buildup? How many times have you been told to add gravel to the bottom of a plant container to improve drainage? Well, guess what? Neither of those is true.

With all the information out there, some of it’s bound to be wrong. Myths tend to stick around, no matter how many times they’re corrected. Oregon State University Extension experts are out to change that. Once you know the truth, pass it on.

For additional questions, call the OSU Extension master gardeners in your area or submit a question to Ask an Expert.

Myth: You should seal wounds on trees.

Reality: Unlike humans who regenerate the cells in their body billions of times during the average lifespan, trees have developed another strategy entirely. When new cells form over a wound, humans heal. Trees do not heal but seal. There are a series of biological walls that begin to form when a tree is wounded that do not allow pathogens to spread by compartmentalizing the wound site. That’s why if you have ever split firewood you often will see the discolored tissue of a wound, surrounded by completely healthy tissue. So, it’s best not to seal a tree wound, which can inhibit the healing of the tree’s wound and allow disease and insects to enter.

– Al Shay, OSU Extension horticulturist

Myth: Grass clippings cause thatch.

Reality: Clippings don't cause thatch, thatch is caused by lateral growth of the grass – more specifically, by rhizomes, which are the below-ground lateral growth, and stolons, the above-ground lateral growth. Turf like creeping bentgrass and Kentucky bluegrass produce rhizomes and stolons. The dominant lawn grass in the Willamette Valley is perennial ryegrass, which does not produce rhizomes or stolons and therefore does not accumulate excessive amounts of thatch. Returning your grass clippings when mowing will actually make grass greener, because you are recycling essential nutrients like nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium back into the soil.

– Alec Kowalewski, OSU Extension turf specialist

Myth: It’s a good idea to add gravel to the bottom of plant containers to improve drainage.

Reality: This practice in fact does the opposite and makes the soil more waterlogged. Instead, make sure your pots have drainage holes and use high-quality potting media specific to your needs. Mixes with smaller particles and high components of vermiculite, peat or compost will hold water better for your water-loving plants than a mix with larger particles such as bark, which will have more drainage for those plants that don’t like wet feet.

– Heather Stoven, OSU Extension horticulturist

Myth: Add sand to loosen clay soil

Reality: A resounding “no” is the answer. When sand is added to clayey soil, it will set up into rock-hard adobe once it is watered, making it even more difficult for plants to grow.

What should you add to clay soil to loosen it up? Compost. The addition of organic matter to clayey soil will improve the soil structure, creating more pores and thereby improving the drainage and the capacity for plant roots to work their way through the soil. For a new garden area, work in three to four inches of compost into the soil with a shovel or spading fork. This organic matter will also help to feed the millions of microbes in the soil, helping to drive the soil food web.

– Weston Miller, OSU Extension horticulturist

Myth: Drought-tolerant plants never need irrigation.

Reality: A drought-tolerant plants is one that, when established, would require no supplemental water and will still grow and flower normally. It would get by on what falls from the sky. If you are considering native plants for the garden, then most of the native plants of Oregon (streamside or wetland plants excepted, of course) would fit that definition. Many non-native plants may also be grown without supplemental irrigation. However, all these plants will at least require irrigation to get established. If planted in the spring, they may require irrigation at planting and periodically through the first summer. In mild areas such as western Oregon, the best way to establish drought-tolerant plants is to plant them in the fall and water until it starts to rain. This will get a truly drought-tolerant plant established by the following summer.

– Neil Bell, OSU Extension horticulturist

Was this page helpful?

Related Content from OSU Extension

Ask Extension

Have a question? Ask Extension!

Ask Extension is a way for you to get answers from the Oregon State University Extension Service. We have experts in family and health, community development, food and agriculture, coastal issues, forestry, programs for young people, and gardening.